I’ve written several drafts of this review. After many revisions, I’m still not quite sure where I stand on this one.
The Women of Troy takes place after the fall of the ancient city, Troy, and offers glimpses into the lives of Trojan women, captured and taken as slaves for the Greeks. For lack of a better way to describe it, I have such weird feelings about this book. There is definitely a good deal of political intrigue, which I’m a sucker for.
The Greek camp, stationed outside of Troy, is ruled over by five kings, each with a different group loyal to him. You have Odysseus, largely considered the brains behind the final assault on Troy (the Trojan horse was his idea); Agamemnon, generally considered to rule with an iron fist; his brother Menelaus, much maligned for his undying love of Helen of Troy (the relationship is considered the catalyst for war); Nestor, an elderly and ailing but highly respected man; And finally, Pyrrhus, teenage son of the late Achilles, who is constantly trying to live up to his father’s reputation.
Even after Troy falls to the Greeks, the fighters can’t leave because constant high winds prevent them from sailing. They are left to wonder which gods they have offended and how they can make the best of this situation. Possibly because they have been stuck on Trojan shores for weeks, tensions are always raised between the factions and they regularly appear on the brink of conflict. However, they always remain on the brink, about to spill over but never doing so in a major way. That is possibly my biggest gripe with the book. Nothing much happens until about page 155 of 284. For me, that pacing is painfully slow. I nearly gave up on it!
Also, and this is more of an observation than a complaint, The Women of Troy does not feel like it’s about women, at least not as much as you’d think. This is going to be the hardest for me to explain because it’s a feeling in my bones more than anything. Yes, a majority of the book is told from a woman’s point of view. Briseis was a former queen of Lyrnessus until Achilles sacked her city and took her as “prize of honor”. Though Achilles is now dead, she is pregnant with his child throughout this book and their relationship somehow remains complicated.
It’s through her eyes that we learn about women’s lives and roles in this camp. And yes, we do occasionally get glimpses at the desires and motivations of these women, these are mostly communicated through internal monologues or scenes here and there. It’s worth noting though that some of the chapters are narrated in a close third person and follow either Pyrrhus or Calchas, a seer or priest. Though the change of perspective is not always clearly communicated, we do learn a lot about these characters. We get hints at their internal struggles and vulnerabilities, in a way that is very similar to the women. However, on both of these ends we see a struggle within a patriarchal system built on reputation. This book really isn’t about the women of Troy in the strict sense. You’d be more apt to call it the cruelty of man. The cruelty of man against woman, sure. But also, the cruelty of man amongst his brothers and himself.
I will say, what this book may lack in pacing was clearly put into character development. All of these characters feel richly developed and it is for them that I’m considering visiting the novel previous to this, The Silence of the Girls, which apparently gives more backstory to Briseis.
I really feel like I need to sit with my feelings a bit more on this one. If you are a patient reader, I definitely recommend this one. However, if you’re looking for a fast-paced action-packed plot, maybe it’s not the right novel. If anything, the characters are a major saving grace no matter what.




